Hall of Fame
As a wide receiver for the Allegheny football team, Carroll caught 57 passes for 757 yards and 10 touchdowns, earned four varsity letters and won the F. Dawson "Duffy" Weber Outstanding Back Award in 1972. He led the team in punt returns in 1972 and 1973. Carroll received three letters as a leftfielder on the baseball team and was once selected All-Presidents' Athletic Conference. He was baseball captain and Allegheny Athlete of the Year in 1974.