Skip To Main Content

Allegheny College Athletics

The Official Athletics Site Of The Allegheny Gators

Football All-Time Results



1893-1930 | 1931-1950 | 1951 - 1970 | 1971 - 1990 | 1991 - 2010 | 2011 - 2020


1893
Record: 1-4
Coach: None
Captain: T.J. Prather
Meadville A.C...................... W............................. 18-0
Oil City A.C........................... L............................. 0-12
Titusville A.C........................ L............................... 0-4
Hiram.................................... L............................. 0-64
Thiel...................................... L............................... 0-4
 
1894
Record: 0-2
Coach: None
Captain: T.J. Prather
Thiel...................................... L............................. 0-12
Franklin A.C.......................... L............................... 0-4
 
1895
Banned by Faculty Action
 
1896
Record: 2-2
Coach: None
Captain: C.B. Allen
Thiel...................................... L............................... 0-4
Jamestown A.C.................. W............................... 4-0
Jamestown A.C.................. W............................. 16-0
at Thiel.................................. L............................. 6-24
 
1897
Record: 0-3
Coach: Charles N. Crosby
Captain: C.J. Wolfe
at Conneaut A.C................... L............................. 6-16
at Thiel.................................. L............................. 0-12
Thiel...................................... L............................. 0-22
 
1898
Record: 4-4
Coach: Martin Smallwood
Captain: W.S. Borland
Meadville H.S...................... W............................. 48-0
at Jamestown A.C............... L............................. 0-32
Thiel.................................... W............................... 6-0
Erie A.C................................ L............................. 0-27
Wash. & Jeff........................ L............................. 0-68
at Thiel.................................. L............................. 0-18
Oil City A.C.......................... W............................. 49-0
Meadville A.C...................... W............................. 36-0
 
1899
Record: 7-2-2
Coach: Alonzo G. Brown
Captain: W.S. Borland
Union City............................ W............................... 9-0
at Westminster..................... L............................. 6-16
Geneva............................... W............................... 6-0
at Thiel.................................. T............................... 5-5
at Grove City........................ T............................... 6-6
Meadville A.C...................... W............................. 28-0
Thiel.................................... W............................. 11-0
at Franklin A.C...................... L............................... 0-5
Grove City........................... W............................. 24-0
Franklin A.C........................ W............................. 23-0
Westminster........................ W........................... 18-11
 
1900
Record: 5-3
Coach: Fred E. Heckel
Captain: A.S. Frazier
at Geneva............................ L............................. 0-11
at Westminster..................... L............................. 0-11
Grove City........................... W............................... 6-0
Warren A.C......................... W............................. 15-0
Jamestown A.C.................. W............................. 22-0
at Grove City........................ L............................... 0-6
Geneva............................... W............................. 21-0
Westminster........................ W............................... 6-0
 
1901
Record: 6-5-1
Coach: Edward N. Eisenberg
Captain: H.W. Taylor
Grove City........................... W............................. 11-0
at Westminster..................... L............................. 0-11
Geneva................................ L............................. 0-11
at W. Pa. (Pitt)...................... L............................. 0-11
at Thiel................................ W............................. 17-0
Oil City A.C.......................... W............................. 72-0
at Geneva............................ L............................. 0-34
at Grove City........................ L............................. 0-12
Thiel.................................... W............................. 12-6
at Western Reserve............. T............................... 6-6
W. Pa. (Pitt)......................... W............................. 15-0
Westminster........................ W............................. 11-0
 
1902
Record: 7-3
Coach: William C. Welker
Captain: A.G. Williams
Erie A.C............................... W............................... 6-0
Grove City........................... W............................. 17-0
at Westminster..................... L............................... 0-6
at Geneva............................ L............................. 0-49
Buchtel (Akron).................. W............................. 23-6
at Grove City....................... W............................... 6-0
Geneva................................ L............................. 0-16
at W. Pa. (Pitt)..................... W............................... 6-0
Western Reserve............... W............................. 11-0
Westminster........................ W............................... 5-0
 
1903
Record: 5-6
Coach: Walter E. Bachman
Captain: F.B. McCartney
Grove City........................... W............................. 27-0
at Penn State........................ L............................. 5-24
Westminster........................ W............................. 12-0
at Case Tech........................ L............................. 0-40
at Geneva............................ L............................. 0-32
Buffalo................................ W............................. 23-0
Hiram................................... W............................. 19-0
at Grove City........................ L............................. 0-16
Geneva................................ L............................... 0-5
at Franklin A.C...................... L............................. 0-47
Mount Union........................ W............................. 46-0
 
1904
Record: 5-5
Coach: W. Branch Rickey
Captain: L.O. Davenport
Warren A.C......................... W............................... 5-0
at Penn State........................ L............................. 0-50
Hiram................................... W............................. 35-0
at Western Reserve............. L............................. 0-39
Grove City........................... W............................... 6-0
at Westminster..................... L............................. 0-76
at Syracuse......................... L............................. 0-69
Geneva............................... W............................. 11-0
Case Tech............................ L............................. 4-29
Westminster........................ W............................... 6-5
 
1905
Record: 3-8
Coach: W. Branch Rickey
Captain: W.J. McQuiston
Alfred.................................. W............................. 16-0
at Geneva............................ L............................. 0-11
Westminster......................... L............................. 0-33
at Wash. & Jeff.................... L............................. 6-23
Geneva............................... W............................... 6-5
at Westminster..................... L............................. 0-35
Wolverine A.C..................... W............................. 17-0
Franklin A.C.......................... L............................. 0-12
at Wooster........................... L........................... 16-39
at Western Reserve............. L............................. 5-52
Niagara................................. L............................... 0-5
 
1906
Record: 2-7
Coach: Clifford B. Lewis
Captain: R.M. Ginn
at Penn State........................ L............................. 0-26
Grove City........................... W............................... 6-0
at W. Pa. (Pitt)...................... L............................. 0-68
Hiram................................... W............................. 21-6
at Western Reserve............. L............................. 0-24
at Grove City........................ L............................. 0-16
Carnegie Tech...................... L............................... 0-5
Westminster......................... L............................. 0-17
 
1907
Record: 5-3-2
Coach: H.J. Sheets
Captain: L.L. Benedict
at Mount Union..................... L............................. 6-11
at Grove City....................... W............................... 6-5
at Geneva............................ T............................... 0-0
Niagara................................. T............................... 0-0
at Oberlin.............................. L............................. 0-25
Grove City........................... W............................. 11-4
Hiram................................... W............................. 17-5
Geneva............................... W............................. 11-4
Carnegie Tech.................... W............................... 5-0
Westminster......................... L............................. 5-26
 
1908
Record: 2-4-1
Coach: H.J. Sheets
Captain: L.L. Benedict
at Geneva............................ T............................... 0-0
Hiram................................... W............................... 5-0
at Wash. & Jeff.................... L............................. 0-47
at Carnegie Tech.................. L............................. 0-11
Mount Union......................... L............................... 6-8
Grove City........................... W............................. 10-9
at Westminster..................... L............................... 5-6
 
1909
Record: 2-4-1
Coach: Edward J. Stewart
Captain: E. P. Kennedy
Hiram................................... W............................. 15-5
at Geneva............................ L............................. 5-14
Buchtel (Akron).................... T............................... 5-5
at Mount Union..................... L............................. 0-24
Westminster........................ W........................... 21-11
at Grove City........................ L............................. 0-54
at Carnegie Tech.................. L............................. 0-10
 
1910
Record: 3-1-1
Coach: Edward J. Stewart
Captain: H.T. Lavely
Hiram................................... W............................. 17-5
Geneva............................... W............................. 22-0
Grove City............................ T............................... 6-6
at Carnegie Tech................ W............................. 27-0
at Buchtel (Akron)................ L............................. 6-12
 
1911
Record: 4-4-1
Coach: David L. Dunlap
Captain: L.L. Hawk
at Cornell.............................. L............................. 9-35
Hiram.................................... T............................... 0-0
Kenyon............................... W............................. 24-0
at Mount Union..................... L............................. 0-23
Geneva............................... W............................. 11-0
Carnegie Tech.................... W............................... 5-0
at Grove City........................ L............................. 3-14
at West Virginia.................. W............................. 10-6
at Buchtel (Akron)................ L............................... 0-6
 
1912
Record: 1-5-1
Coach: David L. Dunlap
Captain: L.T. Miller
Hiram.................................... L............................... 0-6
Mount Union......................... L............................. 6-12
at Geneva............................ L............................. 6-17
at West Virginia.................... L............................... 7-8
at Buchtel (Akron)................ T............................... 0-0
Westminster........................ W............................. 44-0
Grove City............................ L............................... 0-9
1913
Record: 7-1
Coach: Charles E. Hammett
Captain: C.A. Gilbert
Thiel.................................... W............................. 41-0
at Hiram............................... W........................... 19-10
at Buchtel (Akron).............. W............................... 6-0
Alfred.................................. W............................. 93-7
Wooster.............................. W........................... 116-0
at Carnegie Tech................ W............................. 17-0
Geneva............................... W............................. 38-0
at Grove City........................ L............................... 8-9
 
1914
Record: 6-0-1
Coach: Charles E. Hammett
Captain: A.F. Munhall
at Geneva........................... W............................. 15-7
at Akron............................... T............................... 3-3
at Rochester....................... W............................... 6-0
Hiram................................... W............................. 51-0
Duquesne........................... W............................. 41-3
at Carnegie Tech................ W............................. 27-7
Grove City........................... W............................. 40-0
 
1915
Record: 5-3
Coach: Charles E. Hammett
Captain: H.H. Pierson
St. Bonaventure.................. W............................. 52-0
at Akron.............................. W............................. 10-6
at Carnegie Tech.................. L............................. 7-40
Rochester........................... W............................. 19-0
at Pittsburgh......................... L............................. 7-42
Hiram................................... W............................. 39-0
Geneva............................... W............................. 19-0
at Grove City........................ L............................... 6-9
 
1916
Record: 4-2-1
Coach: Charles E. Hammett
Captain: M.J. Scannell
Buffalo................................ W............................. 29-0
at Geneva........................... W............................... 6-0
at Carnegie Tech.................. L............................. 0-27
Grove City............................ T............................... 6-6
at Pittsburgh......................... L............................. 0-46
at Rochester....................... W............................... 7-0
at Akron.............................. W............................. 33-0
 
1917
Record: 6-0-1
Coach: Charles E. Hammett
Captain: J.S. Baldwin
Geneva............................... W............................. 39-0
at Carnegie Tech.................. T............................... 0-0
Thiel.................................... W............................. 49-0
at Grove City....................... W............................. 10-6
at Westminster.................... W............................. 21-0
Akron.................................. W............................. 33-0
at Camp Lee........................ W............................... 7-6
 
1918
Record: 2-1
Coach: Carl A. Gilbert
Captain: N.W. Kerr
Westminster........................ W............................... 7-0
Grove City........................... W............................. 36-0
at Geneva............................ L............................. 9-10
 
1919
Record: 1-3-1
Coach: Charles E. Hammett
Captain: J.W. Harbaugh
St. Bonaventure.................. W............................. 20-0
at Grove City........................ L............................. 0-13
at Carnegie Tech.................. L............................... 0-9
Geneva................................ L............................... 0-3
at Westminster..................... T............................... 0-0
 
1920
Record: 1-3-3
Coach: Clarence O. Applegran
Captain: R.L. Baldwin
Thiel...................................... T............................... 0-0
at Colgate............................. T............................... 7-7
Dickinson.............................. L............................... 0-7
Grove City........................... W............................... 3-0
at Carnegie Tech.................. L............................. 0-42
Westminster......................... T............................... 0-0
at Geneva............................ L............................. 0-19
 
1921
Record: 3-4-1
Coach: G. Herbert McCracken
Captain: A.K. Kramer
at Colgate............................. L............................. 0-14
Alfred................................... T............................... 0-0
Grove City............................ L............................... 0-7
at Westminster.................... W............................... 7-6
Carnegie Tech...................... L............................. 0-56
Buffalo................................ W........................... 26-13
at Dickinson.......................... L............................. 6-28
Geneva............................... W............................. 14-7
 
1922
Record: 6-3
Coach: G. Herbert McCracken
Captain: H.H. Loomis
at Colgate............................. L............................. 0-19
Niagara............................... W............................. 39-0
at Grove City........................ L........................... 13-20
Waynesburg....................... W............................. 33-7
Carnegie Tech...................... L............................... 0-7
Westminster........................ W............................. 68-0
Alfred.................................. W............................. 33-7
at Geneva........................... W............................. 28-7
at Thiel................................ W............................. 25-0
 
1923
Record: 7-1
Coach: G. Herbert McCracken
Captain: H.P. Morley
Thiel.................................... W............................. 14-0
at West Virginia.................... L............................. 0-28
Grove City........................... W............................... 6-0
at Rochester....................... W............................. 39-6
Geneva............................... W............................. 14-0
St. Bonaventure.................. W............................. 14-0
at Westminster.................... W............................. 47-0
at Bucknell.......................... W............................. 10-7
 
1924
Record: 5-2
Coach: Thomas V. Davies
Captain: F.A. Parnell
Dickinson............................ W............................... 7-0
at West Virginia.................... L............................. 6-35
at Thiel................................ W............................. 14-0
at Boston.............................. L............................. 0-13
at Grove City....................... W............................... 9-0
Westminster........................ W............................... 7-0
at Waynesburg................... W............................. 28-0
 
1925
Record: 5-3
Coach: Thomas V. Davies
Captain: J.V. Hanlon
West Virginia........................ L............................. 0-18
Geneva............................... W............................. 14-0
St. Bonaventure.................. W............................. 20-6
at Boston.............................. L............................. 7-14
Waynesburg....................... W............................... 6-0
Thiel.................................... W............................. 14-0
at Grove City........................ L............................. 0-27
at Westminster.................... W............................. 47-0
 
1926
Record: 4-5
Coach: Melvin P. Merritt
Captain: J.M. Kinnunen
at Pittsburgh......................... L............................... 7-9
at New York......................... L............................. 0-13
at West Virginia.................... L............................. 0-54
Bethany.............................. W............................. 14-7
St. Francis.......................... W............................. 34-0
Grove City............................ L............................. 7-14
at Thiel................................ W............................... 6-0
Canisius.............................. W............................. 12-0
at Geneva............................ L............................. 0-15
 
1927
Record: 0-7-1
Coach: Melvin P. Merritt
Captain: D.H. Behrhorst
St. Bonaventure................... L............................... 0-6
at Dartmouth......................... L............................. 0-38
Westminster......................... T............................... 0-0
at Grove City........................ L............................. 6-21
at Pittsburgh......................... L............................. 0-52
Thiel...................................... L............................... 0-2
Geneva................................ L............................. 7-39
at New York......................... L............................. 0-81
 
1928
Record: 4-3-1
Coach: Melvin P. Merritt
Captain: C. Slaven
Mount Union........................ W............................. 32-0
at Westminster.................... W............................. 13-7
at Dartmouth......................... L........................... 12-37
at Pittsburgh......................... L............................. 0-29
Grove City............................ L............................. 7-13
at Thiel.................................. T............................... 6-6
at Geneva........................... W............................... 8-7
Alfred.................................. W............................. 27-0
 
1929
Record: 2-4-2
Coach: Harry W. Crum
Captain: R.M. Garbark
Geneva................................ T........................... 13-13
Westminster......................... L............................... 6-7
at Dartmouth......................... L............................. 0-53
Pittsburgh............................. L............................. 0-40
Thiel...................................... T............................... 0-0
at Grove City........................ L............................. 7-40
Waynesburg....................... W............................. 14-7
at St. Vincent...................... W............................. 28-6
 
1930
Record: 6-2
Coach: Harry W. Crum
Captain: R.M. Garbark
Edinboro.............................. W............................. 21-0
at Westminster.................... W............................... 7-6
at Thiel................................ W............................... 6-0
Adrian................................. W............................. 31-0
Grove City........................... W............................... 6-0
at Dartmouth......................... L........................... 14-43
Salem.................................. W............................. 20-0
at Geneva............................ L........................... 13-27
 
1931
Record: 6-1-2
Coach: Harry W. Crum
Captains: R.M. Garbark, F.P. Morse
Clarion................................. W............................. 45-0
Edinboro.............................. W............................. 27-7
Westminster........................ W............................. 39-7
at Thiel................................ W............................. 21-0
Adrian................................. W............................. 26-0
at Grove City........................ T............................... 7-7
at St. Bonaventure.............. W............................... 7-6
Geneva................................ T............................... 0-0
at W.V. Wesleyan................ L............................. 7-38
 
1932
Record: 1-5-1
Coach: Waldo S. Tippin
Captain: K.V. Waite
Edinboro............................... L............................... 0-7
at Springfield........................ L............................. 0-25
Dickinson.............................. L............................. 0-13
at Ithaca............................... L............................. 0-12
Oberlin.................................. L............................... 6-7
Alfred.................................. W............................. 16-0
at Bethany............................ T............................... 0-0
 
1933
Record: 0-5
Coach: Waldo S. Trippin
Captain: J.E. Vanaman
at Edinboro........................... L............................... 0-6
Springfield............................ L............................. 0-27
at Dickinson.......................... L............................. 0-14
Marietta................................ L............................... 0-7
at Oberlin.............................. L............................... 0-7
 
1934
Record: 2-4-1
Coach: Waldo S. Trippin
Captain: R.E. Edwards
Clarion................................. W............................... 6-0
at Alfred............................... T............................... 7-7
at Dickinson.......................... L............................. 0-21
Grove City........................... W............................... 6-0
Oberlin.................................. L............................... 0-6
at Thiel.................................. L............................. 0-30
Ithaca................................... L............................. 7-14
 
1935
Record: 2-6
Coach: Karl J. Lawrence
Captains: R.H. Horn, A.S. Widmann
Clarion................................. W............................... 7-0
at Hiram............................... W............................... 6-0
Bethany................................ L............................. 0-13
at Grove City........................ L............................. 0-13
at Dickinson.......................... L............................. 0-40
Thiel...................................... L............................. 0-16
Juniata.................................. L............................. 6-20
at Springfield........................ L............................. 0-19
 
1936
Record: 1-3-2
Coach: Karl J. Lawrence
Captain: W.J. Becker
Hiram................................... W............................... 6-0
at Oberlin.............................. L............................... 0-6
Grove City............................ T............................... 0-0
at Juniata.............................. L............................. 8-20
at Thiel.................................. L............................... 0-6
Westminster......................... T............................... 7-7
 
1937
Record: 5-2
Coach: Karl J. Lawrence
Captain: C.L. Spence
at Buffalo............................. L............................. 7-13
at Haverford......................... L............................. 0-13
Hiram................................... W........................... 21-19
at Grove City....................... W............................... 3-0
at Wash. & Jeff................... W........................... 14-12
Thiel.................................... W............................. 20-0
Westminster........................ W........................... 16-13
 
1938
Record: 3-4
Coach: Karl J. Lawrence
Captain: H.T. Lavely, Jr.
Otterbein............................. W............................. 32-0
Haverford............................. L............................. 0-28
at Hiram................................ L............................. 0-38
Grove City............................ L............................. 0-13
at Buffalo............................. L............................. 0-47
at Thiel................................ W............................... 7-0
at Johns Hopkins................ W............................... 6-0
 
1939                                                 
Record: 0-5-2
Coach: Karl J. Lawrence
Captain: W.H. Cook
at Haverford......................... T........................... 13-13
Oberlin.................................. L............................. 0-27
at Grove City........................ T............................... 0-0
Hiram.................................... L............................. 6-26
Johns Hopkins...................... L............................. 7-13
Thiel...................................... L............................. 0-14
at Susquehanna................... L............................. 0-20
 
1940
Record: 0-7
Coach: Karl J. Lawrence
Captains: R.P. Marasco, R.C. Saylor
Haverford............................. L............................. 0-33
at Oberlin.............................. L............................. 0-43
Grove City............................ L............................. 0-14
at Hiram................................ L............................. 0-28
Susquehanna....................... L........................... 12-27
at Thiel.................................. L............................. 0-26
at Wash. & Jeff.................... L............................. 0-30
 
1941
Record: 1-5
Coach: Alfred C. Werner
Captain: R.P. Marasco
at Haverford......................... L............................. 7-45
at Grove City........................ L............................. 0-13
American............................ W........................... 20-14
at Rochester........................ L............................. 0-34
Thiel...................................... L............................. 0-26
Kenyon................................. L........................... 12-18
 
1942
Record: 1-5
Coach: Alfred C. Werner
Captain: W.T. Pierce
Haverford............................. L............................. 0-33
at Earlham........................... W............................. 32-0
at Kenyon............................. L............................. 0-20
Grove City............................ L............................. 7-13
at Rochester........................ L............................. 0-41
Oberlin.................................. L............................. 0-46
 
1943-45
No Games - World War II
 
1946
Record: 1-6
Coach: Robert M. Garbark
Captain: R.A. Stanton
Earlham............................... W............................... 7-0
Westminster......................... L............................. 0-13
at Grove City........................ L............................. 0-14
at Thiel.................................. L............................. 7-13
Mount Union......................... L............................. 0-25
at Oberlin.............................. L............................. 0-62
at Dickinson.......................... L............................. 6-33
 
1947
Record: 1-4-2
Coach: Louis S. Daddio
Captain: R.A. Carman
Oberlin.................................. L............................. 9-25
at Dickinson.......................... T........................... 14-14
at Westminster.................... W............................. 14-7
Grove City............................ L............................. 7-13
Thiel...................................... L............................. 0-20
at Mount Union..................... L............................. 6-20
at Susquehanna................... T............................... 7-7
 
1948
Record: 6-1
Coach: Louis S. Daddio
Captain: C.A. Wright
at Hamilton.......................... W............................. 19-0
Susquehanna..................... W............................. 14-6
Westminster........................ W............................. 13-0
at Grove City........................ L............................. 0-13
Dickinson............................ W............................. 14-7
at Thiel................................ W............................... 6-0
Earlham............................... W............................. 40-0
 
1949
Record: 4-3-1
Coach: Louis S. Daddio
Captain: C.E. Rimer
Hamilton.............................. W........................... 30-13
at Oberlin............................ W........................... 21-20
at Westminster..................... T............................... 0-0
Grove City............................ L............................. 0-32
Dickinson.............................. L........................... 13-21
Thiel.................................... W........................... 27-14
at Earlham........................... W............................. 48-6
at Geneva............................ L............................. 6-20
 
1950
Record: 2-4-1
Coach: Louis S. Daddio
Captain: G.R. Yarbenet
at Rochester........................ T........................... 12-12
Oberlin.................................. L............................. 0-14
Geneva................................ L............................. 7-20
Carnegie Tech...................... L........................... 13-14
at Grove City....................... W............................. 31-0
at Wooster........................... L........................... 13-20
Westminster........................ W........................... 33-14
 
1951
Record: 1-6-1
Coach: Louis S. Daddio
Captain: R.A. Myers
Rochester............................ L............................. 6-10
at Oberlin.............................. L............................. 0-20
Juniata.................................. T........................... 20-20
at Carnegie Tech.................. L............................. 0-39
Grove City............................ L........................... 18-20
Wooster............................... L............................. 6-20
at Westminster.................... W............................. 19-6
at Dickinson.......................... L........................... 13-31
 
1952
Record: 2-6
Coach: David C. Henderson
Captain: P.W. Roese
Oberlin................................ W........................... 40-33
Dickinson.............................. L............................. 0-18
at Hobart.............................. L............................. 7-26
Carnegie Tech...................... L............................. 0-19
at Grove City....................... W........................... 13-12
at Wooster........................... L........................... 13-52
Westminster......................... L........................... 20-26
at Rochester........................ L............................. 0-38
 
1953
Record: 0-8
Coach: David C. Henderson
Captain: C.E. Richard
Rochester............................ L............................. 6-13
at Carnegie Tech.................. L........................... 12-21
Hobart.................................. L........................... 12-19
at Oberlin.............................. L........................... 13-31
Grove City............................ L............................. 6-25
Wooster............................... L............................. 7-35
Westminster......................... L............................. 0-12
at Thiel.................................. L............................. 6-52
 
1954
Record: 2-6
Coach: William R. Moore
Captain: D.A. Reed
at Wooster........................... L............................. 0-31
Hobart.................................. L............................. 7-32
Thiel...................................... L............................. 6-19
Oberlin................................ W........................... 19-12
at Grovze City...................... L........................... 19-25
at Bethany.......................... W........................... 25-21
Westminster......................... L........................... 14-40
at Geneva............................ L............................. 0-38
 
1955
Record: 2-6
Coach: William R. Moore
Captains: D.M. Barron, D.P. McArdle
Wooster............................... L........................... 13-41
at Hobart.............................. L............................. 7-44
at Thiel.................................. L............................. 0-31
at Oberlin............................ W........................... 33-25
Grove City........................... W............................. 13-7
Bethany................................ L........................... 13-27
at Westminster..................... L............................. 0-34
Geneva................................ L............................. 0-20
 
1956
Record: 4-3-1
Coach: William R. Moore
Captains: J.H. Carman, P.V. Croft
Hobart.................................. L............................. 6-26
at Wash. & Jeff.................... T........................... 14-14
Oberlin................................ W........................... 26-19
at Grove City....................... W........................... 25-19
Bethany.............................. W........................... 33-19
Thiel...................................... L........................... 14-39
at Case Tech........................ L............................. 0-20
at Dickinson........................ W........................... 24-19
 
1957
Record: 3-4-1
Coach: William R. Moore
Captains: T.J. Biggam, J.C. Villa
at Hobart.............................. L............................. 7-26
Wash. & Jeff....................... W............................. 19-0
at Oberlin.............................. T........................... 14-14
Grove City............................ L............................. 0-14
at Bethany............................ L............................. 6-29
Dickinson............................ W............................. 26-2
Case Tech.......................... W............................. 20-0
at Thiel.................................. L............................. 9-19
 
1958
Record: 3-4-1 (PAC: 3-1-1)
Coach: John C. Chuckran
Captains: W.W. Baker, R.M. Buerger
at Rochester........................ L............................. 0-20
Wash. & Jeff....................... W............................... 6-0
Bethany.............................. W............................. 12-8
at Grove City........................ L........................... 16-28
Thiel...................................... T........................... 12-12
at Dickinson.......................... L........................... 12-18
at Case Tech........................ L............................. 6-28
John Carroll......................... W............................. 14-0
 
1959
Record: 6-2 (PAC: 4-1)
Coach: John R. Chuckran
Captains: R.J. Dunn, D.E. Spencer
Rochester............................ L............................... 0-6
at Wash. & Jeff................... W............................. 20-6
at Wayne State.................... L............................. 7-20
Bethany.............................. W........................... 19-16
Grove City........................... W............................. 14-0
Dickinson............................ W............................... 6-0
Case Tech.......................... W............................. 22-0
at Thiel................................ W............................. 14-6
 
1960
Record: 3-3-1 (PAC: 3-3)
Coach: John R. Chuckran
Captains: B.T. Olderman, R.E. Steiner
at Bethany.......................... W............................. 14-6
Wash. & Jeff....................... W............................. 19-7
at Western Reserve............. L............................. 8-34
Case Tech.......................... W............................. 27-0
at Grove City........................ T........................... 24-24
Wayne State........................ L............................. 6-26
Thiel...................................... L........................... 14-16
 
1961
Record: 6-1 (PAC: 5-1)
Coach: John R. Chuckran
Captains: E.D. Ehrenberger, R. Jones
Bethany.............................. W........................... 33-14
at Wash. & Jeff................... W............................. 10-0
Western Reserve............... W............................... 7-0
at Case Tech...................... W........................... 33-14
Grove City........................... W............................. 26-0
at Thiel.................................. L........................... 22-35
 
1962
Record: 2-5 (PAC: 2-3)
Coach: John R. Chuckran
Captains: W.E. Tracy, J.P. Valentino
at Oberlin.............................. L........................... 20-24
Case Tech.......................... W............................. 27-8
at John Carroll...................... L............................. 0-26
Rochester............................ L............................. 9-13
at Bethany............................ L........................... 14-16
Wash. & Jeff........................ L........................... 12-21
Thiel.................................... W............................. 12-6
 
1963
Record: 4-3 (PAC: 2-3)
Coach: John R. Chuckran
Captains: W.G. Dolde, S.L. Simonton
Hiram................................... W........................... 13-12
at Case Tech........................ L........................... 26-27
at Rochester....................... W........................... 24-12
Wayne State....................... W........................... 22-21
Bethany.............................. W........................... 27-19
at Wash. & Jeff.................... L........................... 12-25
at Thiel.................................. L............................. 8-31
 
1964
Record: 3-5 (PAC: 2-4)
Coach: John R. Chuckran
Captains: C.W. Stenberg, D.A. Wion
Wayne State....................... W............................... 7-0
at Hiram................................ L............................. 6-35
Carnegie Tech.................... W............................. 13-3
at E. Michigan....................... L............................. 7-28
Bethany................................ L............................. 0-29
at Wash. & Jeff.................... L............................... 6-7
Western Reserve................. L............................. 7-14
at Thiel................................ W........................... 18-13
 
1965
Record: 3-5 (PAC: 2-4)
Coach: John R. Chuckran
Captains: J.P. Butler, H.N. Valentino
at Wayne State.................... L............................... 0-7
Oberlin................................ W........................... 26-15
at Carnegie Tech.................. L............................. 6-27
E. Michigan........................... L............................. 8-23
at Bethany............................ L............................. 8-20
Wash. & Jeff....................... W........................... 18-16
at Western Reserve............. L........................... 13-20
Thiel.................................... W............................. 26-7
 
1966
Record: 4-3 (PAC: 3-2)
Coach: John R. Chuckran
Captains: W.M. Conner, P. Thompson
at Case Tech...................... W........................... 20-12
Carnegie Tech...................... L............................. 6-19
at Oberlin............................ W............................. 12-0
Bethany................................ L........................... 19-21
at Wash. & Jeff................... W........................... 24-20
John Carroll.......................... L........................... 18-20
at Thiel................................ W............................. 19-8
 
1967
Record: 5-2 (PAC: 3-2)
Coach: John R. Chuckran
Captains: H.A. Black, H.A. Luce
Case Tech.......................... W............................... 8-0
at Carnegie Mellon.............. W........................... 34-20
Oberlin................................ W........................... 33-14
at Bethany............................ L............................. 7-13
Wash. & Jeff....................... W............................. 28-0
at John Carroll..................... W............................. 15-0
Thiel...................................... L............................. 6-22
 
1968
Record: 7-1 (PAC: 6-0)
Coach: John R. Chuckran
Captains: H.A. Luce, J.A. Boughton, P.N. Blufarb
Adelbert.............................. W............................. 16-0
at Bethany.......................... W........................... 29-24
John Carroll......................... W........................... 14-13
at Carnegie Mellon................ L........................... 18-48
at Wash. & Jeff................... W........................... 40-20
Case Tech.......................... W........................... 60-18
at Thiel................................ W........................... 35-32
Rochester........................... W........................... 42-19
 
1969
Record: 5-3 (PAC: 4-2)
Coach: John R. Chuckran
Captains: M.C. Ganey, J.C. Lewis
at Western Reserve........... W........................... 19-15
Bethany................................ L............................. 7-15
at John Carroll...................... L........................... 25-32
Carnegie Mellon.................. W........................... 70-39
Wash. & Jeff....................... W........................... 52-13
at Case Tech...................... W............................. 28-7
Thiel.................................... W........................... 21-14
at Rochester........................ L............................. 0-32
 
1970
Record: 2-5 (PAC: 2-3)
Coach: Sam T. Timer
Captain: L.R. Albright
Case Western..................... W............................. 20-3
Wash. & Jeff........................ L........................... 19-20
at Oberlin.............................. L........................... 20-21
Carnegie Mellon.................... L........................... 15-41
John Carroll.......................... L........................... 14-25
at Bethany............................ L............................... 6-7
at Thiel................................ W............................. 22-8
 
1971
Record: 4-4 (PAC: 2-3)
Coach: Sam T. Timer
Captains: appointed each game
at Plattsburgh...................... W............................. 21-3
at Case Western................. W............................. 21-7
at Wash. & Jeff.................... L........................... 12-28
Oberlin................................ W............................. 21-0
at Carnegie Mellon................ L............................. 7-24
at John Carroll...................... L............................. 0-35
Thiel...................................... L........................... 15-20
Bethany.............................. W............................. 13-6
 
1972
Record: 5-4 (PAC: 5-2)
Coach: Sam T. Timer
Captains: appointed each game
Marietta................................ L............................. 7-27
at John Carroll..................... W............................. 17-7
at Bethany.......................... W........................... 17-10
Case Western...................... L............................. 6-14
Carnegie Mellon.................. W............................. 13-6
Wash. & Jeff....................... W............................. 10-0
at Otterbein.......................... L............................. 7-42
at Thiel.................................. L........................... 18-28
Hiram................................... W............................. 32-0
 
1973
Record: 5-3-1 (PAC: 5-1-1)
Coach: Sam T. Timer
Captains: appointed each game
at Marietta............................ L........................... 22-23
John Carroll.......................... T............................... 7-7
Bethany.............................. W............................. 26-7
at Case Western................. W............................. 42-7
at Carnegie Mellon................ L............................. 0-10
at Wash. & Jeff................... W........................... 42-14
Otterbein.............................. L............................... 8-9
Thiel.................................... W............................... 7-4
at Hiram............................... W........................... 30-20
 
1974
Record: 7-1 (PAC: 6-1)
Coach: Sam T. Timer
Captains: T.M. Clayton, E.J. Pinkham
at Case Western................. W............................. 39-0
Hiram................................... W............................. 26-6
at Bethany............................ L........................... 20-24
Grove City........................... W............................. 33-7
at Wash. & Jeff................... W............................. 26-0
John Carroll......................... W........................... 30-21
Carnegie Mellon.................. W........................... 40-13
at Thiel................................ W........................... 36-14
 
1975
Record: 6-2 (PAC: 5-2)
Coach: Sam T. Timer
Captain: D.J. Slovick
Case Western..................... W............................. 26-0
at Hiram............................... W............................. 32-0
Bethany.............................. W............................. 19-7
at Grove City....................... W........................... 15-10
Wash. & Jeff........................ L........................... 16-21
at John Carroll..................... W........................... 23-21
at Carnegie Mellon................ L............................. 3-23
Thiel.................................... W............................. 21-0
 
1976
Record: 6-2 (PAC: 6-1)
Coach: Sam T. Timer
Captain: D.T. Lillard
Case Western..................... W........................... 24-12
Bethany.............................. W............................. 14-9
at John Carroll..................... W........................... 35-14
at Hiram................................ L............................. 7-14
Wash. & Jeff....................... W............................. 24-7
Carnegie Mellon.................. W........................... 24-22
at Thiel................................ W............................. 31-7
Westminster......................... L............................. 7-10
 
1977
Record: 5-3 (PAC: 5-2)
Coach: Sam T. Timer
Captain: M.J. Matlak, P.L. Spina
Case Western...................... L............................... 0-3
at Bethany.......................... W............................. 14-7
John Carroll......................... W............................. 33-0
Hiram................................... W............................. 13-3
at Wash. & Jeff................... W............................... 9-7
at Carnegie Mellon................ L............................. 7-29
Thiel.................................... W........................... 31-17
at Westminster..................... L............................. 6-20
 
1978
Record: 4-3-1 (PAC: 3-3-1)
Coach: Sam T. Timer
Captains: W. Law, T. Steib, M. Veon
at Bethany.......................... W........................... 14-10
at Hiram................................ L............................... 3-7
Thiel...................................... T............................... 0-0
Case Western..................... W............................. 24-6
at Carnegie Mellon................ L........................... 14-26
at Wash. & Jeff.................... L............................... 0-7
John Carroll......................... W............................. 14-7
Geneva............................... W........................... 27-18
 
1979
Record: 3-5 (PAC: 3-4)
Coach: Sam T. Timer
Captains: appointed each game
Bethany................................ L........................... 17-20
Hiram................................... W............................... 9-7
at Thiel.................................. L............................. 0-28
at Case Western.................. L............................. 31-0
Carnegie Mellon.................... L............................. 0-26
Wash. & Jeff....................... W............................. 34-0
at John Carroll...................... L........................... 14-31
at Geneva............................ L............................. 6-24
 
1980
Record: 3-4-1 (PAC: 3-3-1)
Coach: Sam T. Timer
Captains: T.J. Dougan, D.A.
Dedmak
Albion................................... L........................... 14-21
at Bethany............................ L........................... 13-38
at Carnegie Mellon................ L............................. 0-24
John Carroll.......................... L............................. 0-13
at Case Western................. W........................... 28-17
at Wash. & Jeff................... W............................. 35-7
Hiram.................................... T............................... 7-7
Thiel.................................... W........................... 16-10
 
1981
Record: 3-5 (PAC: 3-4)
Coach: Sam T. Timer
Captains: E. Tommasi, K. McFarland, B. Barcelona
at Albion............................... L............................. 7-19
Bethany................................ L........................... 20-24
Carnegie Mellon.................... L........................... 13-22
at John Carroll...................... L............................... 7-9
Case Western..................... W........................... 38-14
Wash. & Jeff....................... W............................. 29-0
at Hiram................................ L........................... 23-47
at Thiel................................ W........................... 14-22
 
1982
Record: 3-6 (PAC: 3-4)
Coach: Sam T. Timer
Captains: S. Susnak, R. Lamendola, V. Donatelli
Frostburg State.................... L........................... 22-24
Thiel.................................... W........................... 21-19
at Bethany............................ L............................. 7-24
at Carnegie Mellon................ L........................... 10-20
John Carroll......................... W............................... 7-3
Case Western..................... W........................... 27-20
at Wash. & Jeff.................... L........................... 14-16
Hiram.................................... L............................. 3-28
John Carroll.......................... L........................... 14-33
 
1983
Record: 4-5 (PAC: 2-5)
Coach: Sam T. Timer
Captain: R. Fraser
Lebanon Valley................... W........................... 42-20
at Thiel................................ W........................... 15-13
Bethany.............................. W........................... 16-10
Carnegie Mellon.................... L............................. 0-35
at John Carroll...................... L........................... 14-16
at Case Western.................. L........................... 14-28
Wash. & Jeff........................ L............................. 7-21
at Hiram................................ L............................. 6-13
Rochester........................... W............................. 21-7
 
1984
Record: 3-7 (NCAC: 1-5)
Coach: Robert Wolfe
Captains: R. Fraser, M. Grant, J. Null, M. Zampell
Thiel...................................... L............................. 7-14
at Lebanon Valley............... W............................. 28-3
Denison................................ L........................... 14-52
Westminster......................... L............................. 0-41
at Kenyon............................. L........................... 14-28
at Oberlin.............................. L........................... 13-14
Wooster.............................. W........................... 30-29
Case Western...................... L............................. 0-31
at Ohio Wesleyan................. L........................... 17-21
at Grove City....................... W............................... 9-6
 
1985
Record: 3-7 (NCAC: 1-5)
Coach: Robert Wolfe
Captains: M. Fisher, L. Ford, M. Lamendola, D. Trace
at Thiel.................................. L........................... 14-15
Dayton.................................. L............................. 0-28
at Denison............................ L........................... 10-16
at Westminster.................... W............................. 12-7
Kenyon................................. L........................... 14-15
Oberlin.................................. L............................. 3-12
at Wooster........................... L........................... 21-24
at Case Western.................. L........................... 27-35
Ohio Wesleyan................... W............................. 16-6
Grove City........................... W............................. 12-7
 
1986
Record: 6-4 (NCAC: 4-2)
Coach: Peter Vaas
Captains: R. Schumacher, D. Simko, J. Stiefvater
Carnegie Mellon.................... L............................. 7-36
Denison................................ L........................... 24-28
at Oberlin............................ W............................. 10-0
at Wooster.......................... W............................. 16-7
Ohio Wesleyan................... W............................. 21-0
Case Western...................... L............................. 3-21
at Thiel................................ W............................. 35-0
at Kenyon........................... W............................. 21-3
at Grove City........................ L............................. 0-23
Wash. & Lee....................... W............................. 34-0
 
1987
Record: 9-1-1 (NCAC: 6-0)
Coach: Peter Vaas
Captains: B. Currie, S. Grava
at Carnegie Mellon................ T............................... 7-7
at Denison........................... W........................... 23-20
Oberlin................................ W............................. 17-6
Wooster.............................. W............................... 6-3
at Ohio Wesleyan............... W............................. 44-6
at Case Western................. W........................... 30-16
Thiel.................................... W............................. 28-6
Kenyon............................... W............................. 27-7
Grove City........................... W............................. 27-7
at Swarthmore.................... W........................... 30-24
NCAA Playoffs
Wash. & Jeff........................ L...................... 17-23(ot)
 
1988
Record: 8-2 (NCAC: 6-0)
Coach: Peter Vaas
Captains: J. Giliberto, M. Mulhair
at Mount Union..................... L............................. 7-15
Thiel.................................... W........................... 50-14
at Oberlin............................ W............................. 31-8
at Wooster.......................... W........................... 24-10
Case Western..................... W........................... 31-21
John Carroll......................... L........................... 14-33
at Kenyon........................... W........................... 44-28
Denison............................... W............................... 7-0
Ohio Wesleyan................... W............................. 10-3
Swarthmore........................ W........................... 34-13
 
1989
Record: 6-4 (NCAC: 5-2)
Coach: Peter Vaas
Captains: D. Carr, T. Gebhardt,  J. Logue
Mount Union......................... L............................. 7-27
at Thiel................................ W............................. 30-0
Oberlin................................ W........................... 38-13
Wittenberg.......................... W............................. 24-7
at Case Western................. W........................... 28-14
at Earlham........................... W........................... 15-10
Kenyon................................. L........................... 18-19
at Denison........................... W........................... 24-14
at Ohio Wesleyan................. L............................. 7-18
Rochester............................ L........................... 19-26
 
1990 - NATIONAL CHAMPIONS
Record: 13-0-1 (NCAC: 7-0)
Coach: Ken O'Keefe
Captains: D. LaCarte, J. Marzka
at Juniata.............................. T........................... 30-30
at Oberlin............................ W........................... 29-18
Denison............................... W........................... 40-15
at Earlham........................... W............................. 62-0
at Wooster.......................... W........................... 38-14
Wittenberg.......................... W............................. 38-0
at Kenyon........................... W........................... 24-18
Ohio Wesleyan................... W........................... 14-10
Duquesne........................... W............................. 51-0
at Rochester....................... W............................. 14-7
NCAA Playoffs
at Mount Union.................... W........................... 26-15
Dayton................................ W........................... 31-23
at Central (Iowa)................. W............................. 24-7
Amos Alonzo Stagg Bowl
Lycoming............................ W........................ 21-14 (ot)
 
1991
Record: 11-1 (NCAC: 7-0)
Coach: Ken O'Keefe
Captains: D. Hadlock, J. Lacayo
at Carnegie Mellon.............. W........................... 23-12
Juniata................................ W........................... 19-10
Oberlin................................ W............................. 37-2
at Denison........................... W........................... 63-20
Earlham............................... W............................. 75-0
Wooster.............................. W............................. 34-6
at Wittenberg...................... W........................... 22-16
Kenyon............................... W........................... 43-21
at Ohio Wesleyan............... W............................. 24-7
at Duquesne....................... W............................. 35-0
NCAA Playoffs
Albion.................................. W...................... 24-21(ot)
Dayton.................................. L......................... 25-28(ot)
 
1992
Record: 8-2 (NCAC: 7-1)
Coach: Ken O'Keefe
Captains: R. Bendekovic, W. Mack
at Westminster..................... L............................. 0-20
at Wooster.......................... W............................. 44-3
Case Western..................... W............................. 32-0
Carnegie Mellon.................. W........................... 35-21
at Wittenberg........................ L........................... 12-17
Kenyon............................... W........................... 48-14
at Oberlin............................ W............................. 56-0
Denison............................... W........................... 53-13
at Ohio Wesleyan............... W........................... 32-25
Earlham............................... W............................. 68-6
 
1993
Record: 9-2 (NCAC: 8-0)
Coach: Ken O'Keefe
Captains: A. Barkley, M. Spoerke
Westminster......................... L........................... 17-24
Wooster.............................. W............................. 44-3
at Case Western................. W............................. 51-7
at Carnegie Mellon.............. W............................. 20-9
Wittenberg.......................... W........................... 25-14
at Kenyon........................... W............................. 59-7
Oberlin................................ W............................. 45-7
at Denison........................... W............................. 63-7
Ohio Wesleyan................... W............................. 51-7
at Earlham........................... W............................. 45-6
NCAA Playoffs
at Mount Union..................... L............................. 7-40
 
1994
Record: 10-1 (NCAC: 8-0)
Coach: Ken O'Keefe
Captains: A. Wilson, T. Susec, B. Kalkowski
Carnegie Mellon.................. W........................... 37-22
at Denison........................... W............................. 42-0
Wittenberg.......................... W........................... 27-12
at Case Western................. W............................. 69-6
Earlham............................... W........................... 60-14
at Westminster.................... W............................. 14-9
at Kenyon........................... W............................. 54-0
Wooster.............................. W............................. 62-7
at Ohio Wesleyan............... W........................... 22-14
Oberlin................................ W............................. 83-0
NCAA Playoffs
Mount Union......................... L........................... 19-28
 
1995
Record: 9-1 (NCAC: 7-1)
Coach: Ken O'Keefe
Captains: B. Adams, A. Park
at Carnegie Mellon.............. W............................. 34-7
Denison............................... W............................. 31-7
at Wittenberg........................ L........................... 17-31
Case Western..................... W............................. 50-0
at Earlham........................... W........................... 34-14
Westminster........................ W........................... 17-10
Kenyon............................... W........................... 69-13
at Wooster.......................... W........................... 57-12
Ohio Wesleyan................... W............................. 61-0
at Oberlin............................ W............................. 55-0
 
1996
Record: 10-1 (NCAC: 8-0)
Coach: Ken O'Keefe
Captains: K. Smesko, N. Reiser
Thiel.................................... W........................... 61-13
at Wittenberg...................... W........................... 26-14
Ohio Wesleyan................... W............................. 35-6
at Denison........................... W........................... 72-19
Case Western..................... W........................... 56-12
at Wooster.......................... W............................. 13-3
Earlham............................... W............................. 58-7
at Brockport........................ W............................. 14-3
at Kenyon........................... W............................. 57-6
Oberlin................................ W............................. 61-7
NCAA Playoffs
at Mount Union..................... L........................... 26-31
 
1997
Record: 9-2 (NCAC: 7-1)
Coach: Ken O'Keefe
Captains: J. Mormino, S. Rado, S. Smith
at Thiel................................ W........................... 45-19
Wittenberg............................ L........................... 17-29
at Ohio Wesleyan............... W........................... 37-21
Denison............................... W............................. 34-3
at Case Western................. W........................... 55-20
Wooster.............................. W........................... 28-27
at Earlham........................... W........................... 35-21
Brockport State................... W........................... 43-10
Kenyon............................... W........................... 38-10
at Oberlin............................ W........................... 75-16
NCAA Playoffs
at Mount Union..................... L........................... 30-34
 
1998
Record: 8-2 (NCAC: 6-1)
Coach: Blair Hrovat
Captains: C. Belaney, Z. Kessler, N. Six
Wash. & Jeff........................ L........................... 14-23
at Denison........................... W........................... 44-19
at Susquehanna................. W........................... 35-30
at Wittenberg........................ L............................. 0-25
Kenyon............................... W............................. 56-0
Earlham............................... W............................. 59-7
at Wooster.......................... W...................... 40-39(ot)
at Ohio Wesleyan............... W............................. 27-0
Gannon............................... W............................. 37-0
Oberlin................................ W............................. 71-0
 
1999
Record: 6-4 (NCAC: 4-2)
Coach: Blair Hrovat
Captains: C. Belaney, D. Monaghan
at Malone.............................. L............................... 0-7
at Wash. & Jeff.................... L........................... 13-19
Denison............................... W........................... 30-13
Ohio Wesleyan................... W............................. 17-3
Wooster............................... L...................... 10-13(ot)
Wittenberg............................ L........................... 17-20
at Earlham........................... W............................. 67-0
at Kenyon........................... W............................. 42-0
Buffalo State....................... W............................. 48-8
St. Francis (Ill.).................... W...................... 61-55(ot)
 
2000
Record: 7-3 (NCAC: 6-1)
Coach: Blair Hrovat
Captains: J. Snyder, J. Rossi
Mount Union......................... L........................... 21-48
Wash. & Jeff........................ L........................... 41-54
Frostburg State................... W........................... 31-13
at Denison........................... W............................. 39-8
Wittenberg............................ L........................... 21-35
at Hiram............................... W............................. 70-7
Kenyon............................... W............................. 50-0
at Wabash.......................... W........................... 54-45
at Wooster.......................... W........................... 43-15
Ohio Wesleyan................... W........................... 22-14
 
2001
Record: 5-5 (NCAC: 4-3)
Coach: Blair Hrovat
Captains: T. Creahan, J. McNeilly, S. Ream
at Mount Union..................... L............................. 7-52
at Wash. & Jeff.................... L........................... 14-28
Denison............................... W........................... 55-21
at Wittenberg........................ L........................... 17-21
Hiram................................... W............................. 57-0
at Kenyon........................... W........................... 68-13
at Frostburg State............... W........................... 40-13
Wabash................................ L........................... 20-41
Wooster.............................. W............................. 28-7
at Ohio Wesleyan................. L........................... 47-51
 
2002
Record: 5-5 (NCAC: 4-3)
Coach: Mark Matlak
Captains: appointed each game
Baldwin-Wallace.................. L............................. 2-22
Wash. & Jeff....................... W........................... 28-25
at Westminster..................... L........................... 13-24
at Wabash............................ L........................... 14-24
Hiram................................... W............................. 56-0
Wooster............................... L............................. 7-21
at Denison........................... W........................... 50-16
at Wittenberg........................ L............................. 3-49
Earlham............................... W............................. 28-7
at Ohio Wesleyan............... W........................... 30-16
 
2003
Record: 7-4 (NCAC: 7-0)
Coach: Mark Matlak
Captains: M. Komar, D. Pisanick, J. Turner
at Baldwin-Wallace.............. L........................... 26-45
at Wash. & Jeff.................... L........................... 23-28
Westminster......................... L......................... 0-3 (ot)
Wabash.............................. W............................... 7-6
at Hiram............................... W........................... 37-14
at Wooster.......................... W........................... 26-20
Denison............................... W............................. 37-0
Wittenberg.......................... W........................... 27-21
at Earlham........................... W........................... 42-21
Ohio Wesleyan................... W........................... 20-12
NCAA Playoffs
at Montclair State................. L........................... 19-20
 
2004
Record: 5-5 (NCAC: 4-3)
Coach: Mark Matlak
Captains: J. Brady, C. Devlin,  P. Huffman, S. Williams
Baldwin-Wallace.................. L........................... 14-27
at Westminster.................... W..................... 21-14 (ot)
Wash. & Jeff........................ L............................. 7-29
at Wooster........................... L........................... 13-35
at Ohio Wesleyan................. L........................... 14-17
Kenyon............................... W............................. 42-9
Hiram................................... W............................. 59-0
at Wabash.......................... W...................... 16-10(ot)
Earlham............................... W............................. 26-7
at Wittenberg........................ L........................... 21-42
 
2005
Record: 3-7 (NCAC: 3-4)
Coach: Mark Matlak
Captains: E. George, D. Monarko, M. Fonzi, M. Gelles
at Baldwin-Wallace.............. L...................... 17-23(ot)
Westminster......................... L........................ 9-12(ot)
at Wash. & Jeff.................... L........................... 21-45
Wooster............................... L........................... 34-37
Ohio Wesleyan..................... L............................. 8-13
at Kenyon............................. L........................... 27-34
at Hiram............................... W............................. 38-6
Wabash................................ L........................... 21-27
at Earlham........................... W............................. 41-0
Wittenberg.......................... W........................... 31-21
 
2006
Record: 6-4 (NCAC: 4-3)
Coach: Mark Matlak
Captains: appointed each game
at Westminster.................... W........................... 35-10
at Wash. & Jeff.................... L........................... 10-22
Hiram................................... W............................. 52-7
at Denison........................... W............................. 23-6
at Wabash............................ L........................... 27-41
Kenyon............................... W........................... 49-38
at Wooster........................... L........................... 21-27
Ohio Wesleyan................... W........................... 30-13
at Wittenberg........................ L........................... 21-39
Oberlin................................ W........................... 35-14
 
2007
Record: 5-5 (NCAC: 3-4)
Coach: Mark Matlak
Captains: appointed each game
at Westminster..................... L............................. 6-13
Hiram................................... W............................. 20-7
at Car. Mellon...................... W........................... 24-21
Denison............................... W............................. 14-0
Wabash................................ L........................... 20-28
at Kenyon........................... W............................. 24-0
Wooster.............................. W........................... 27-20
at Ohio Wesleyan................. L........................ W10-17
Wittenberg............................ L............................. 6-17
at Oberlin.............................. L........................... 22-27
 
2008
Record: 5-5 (NCAC: 4-3)
Coach: Mark Matlak
Captains: M. Cellini, B. Jones, C. Lawrence, A. Stas
at Juniata............................ W........................... 34-18
at Westminster..................... L............................... 2-6
Oberlin................................ W........................... 24-13
at Wabash............................ L............................. 7-48
at Denison............................ L........................... 10-13
Kenyon............................... W........................... 27-22
at Wooster........................... L........................... 21-35
Wittenberg.......................... W...................... 30-27(ot)
Ohio Wesleyan................... W........................ 10-7(ot)
 
2009
Record: 8-2 (NCAC 5-2)
Coach: Mark Matlak
Captains: C. Bell, T. Salopek
Juniata................................ W............................. 13-0
Westminster........................ W........................... 27-14
at Oberlin............................ W............................. 22-0
Wabash................................ L............................. 3-37
at Carnegie Mellon.............. W........................... 38-35
Denison............................... W........................... 24-21
at Kenyon........................... W........................... 21-18
Wooster.............................. W........................... 24-21
at Wittenberg........................ L........................... 10-52
at Ohio Wesleyan............... W........................... 30-13
 
 
2010                                                         
Record: 7-3 (NCAC: 4-2)
Coach: Mark Matlak
Captain: T.  Salopek, J. Mitchell, K. Beach, S. Facaros
at Bethany.......................... W............................. 28-0
Carnegie Mellon.................. W........................... 34-27
Wittenberg............................ L........................... 21-24
at Case Western.................. L........................... 23-24
Kenyon............................... W............................. 24-0
at Denison........................... W........................... 17-16
Ohio Wesleyan................... W........................... 41-21
at Wabash............................ L............................. 3-20
at Hiram............................... W........................... 43-21
at Oberlin............................ W........................... 17-14
 
2011                                                         
Record: 5-5 (NCAC: 3-3)
Coach: Mark Matlak
Captain: S. Taylor, D. Williams
Bethany................................ L............................. 7-28
at Carnegie Mellon.............. W........................... 33-13
DePauw.............................. W........................... 17-10
at Wittenberg........................ L............................. 3-38
Case Western...................... L........................... 10-17
at Kenyon........................... W........................... 31-17
Denison............................... W........................... 31-28
Wabash................................ L........................... 16-22
Hiram................................... W........................... 44-14
Oberlin.................................. L........................... 13-14
 
2012                                                        
Record: 5-5 (NCAC: 4-3)
Coach: Mark Matlak
Captains: R. Destefano, T. O'Brien, J. Douglas, C. Sharp
at Wooster.......................... W........................... 17-14
Carnegie Mellon.................... L............................. 7-37
at Wabash.......................... W........................... 20-17
Oberlin................................ W............................. 15-3
at Chicago............................ L............................. 0-10
DePauw.............................. W........................... 22-20
Wittenberg............................ L............................. 6-35
at Kenyon............................. L............................. 7-20
Ohio Wesleyan..................... L............................. 7-34
at Hiram............................... W............................. 13-0
2013                                                       
Record: 0-10 (NCAC: 0-9)
Coach: Mark Matlak
Captains: B. Burkley, S. Beal, J. Szoszorek, T. Pryor
Carnegie Mellon.................... L............................. 7-37
Kenyon................................. L............................. 7-38
at Carnegie Mellon................ L............................. 7-26
Hiram.................................... L............................. 0-20
Wabash................................ L............................. 0-65
at Ohio Wesleyan................. L............................. 7-50
Wooster............................... L........................... 16-33
at Oberlin.............................. L............................. 0-24
at DePauw........................... L............................. 7-23
Denison................................ L........................... 21-24
at Wittenberg........................ L............................. 0-56
2014                                                       
Record: 1-9 (NCAC: 1-8)
Coach: Mark Matlak
Captains: J. Battaglia, A. Niklaus, P. Jones, R. Sherry
Thiel...................................... L........................... 14-28
at Hiram............................... W........................... 24-21
Wabash................................ L............................. 0-63
Ohio Wesleyan..................... L........................... 19-36
at Wooster........................... L........................... 21-42
Oberlin.................................. L............................. 9-37
DePauw............................... L............................. 7-59
at Kenyon............................. L........................... 24-35
at Denison............................ L............................. 7-45
Wittenberg............................ L........................... 21-52
 
2015                                                       
Record: 0-10 (NCAC 0-9)
Coach: Mark Matlak
Captains: C. Patrick, T. Smith, Z. Harvey, N. Deichler
at Thiel.................................. L........................... 21-37
Wooster............................... L........................... 13-28
Wabash................................ L........................... , 0-54
Kenyon................................. L.......................... 17-32
at Oberlin.............................. L............................ 9-48
at DePauw........................... L............................ 0-50
Denison................................ L............................ 7-33
Hiram.................................... L........................... 13-43
at Ohio Wesleyan................. L............................ 9-39
at Wittenberg........................ L............................. 0-63
 
2016                                                      
Record: 1-9 (NCAC 1-8)
Coach: B.J. Hammer
Captains: J. Nigro, J. McFarland, J. Scroxton, M. Davenport
Thiel...................................... L........................... 21-44
at Wooster........................... L........................... 40-49
at Wabash............................ L............................. 7-59
at Kenyon............................. L............................. 7-31
Oberlin................................ W........................... 26-21
DePauw............................... L........................... 21-69
at Denison............................ L........................... 28-42
at Hiram................................ L........................... 14-42
Ohio Weslyan....................... L............................. 0-24
Wittenberg............................ L............................. 8-45
 
2017                                                     
Record: 3-7 (NCAC 2-7)
Coach: B.J. Hammer
Captains: B. Stoldt, T. Thomas, A. Murphy, F. Ruiz
at Thiel................................ W............................. 38-6
Wooster............................... L........................... 35-49
Denison................................ L........................... 26-62
at Ohio Wesleyan................. L........................... 21-37
Hiram................................... W........................... 57-40
at Wittenberg........................ L........................... 15-49
Kenyon............................... W........................... 44-35
at DePauw........................... L........................... 26-42
Wabash................................ L........................... 41-48
at Oberlin.............................. L........................... 37-63

2018                                                     
Record: 6-4 (NCAC 6-3)
Coach: B.J. Hammer
Captains: M. Davenport, T. Rhoades, T. Balla, A. Victor, C. Laskey
RPI.......................................L.............................19-40
at Wooster............................W........................... 27-20
at Denison.............................L........................... 0-42
Ohio Wesleyan......................W...........................25-17
at Hiram..................................W........................... 52-20
Wittenberg..............................L........................... 14-41
at Kenyon.............................W........................... 54-10
DePauw................................W........................... 20-19
at Wabash..............................L........................... 17-54
Oberlin....................................W........................... 47-14

2019                                                    
Record: 4-6 (NCAC 4-5)
Coach: Rich Nagy
Captains: appointed each game
at RPI.......................................L.............................14-52
Wabash............................L........................... 35-48
at Ohio Wesleyan.............................L........................... 10-28
Denison......................L...........................7-42
at Wittenberg..................................L........................... 14-52
Kenyon..............................W........................... 49-0
at DePauw.............................L........................... 6-8
Hiram................................W........................... 45-22
Wooster..............................W........................... 24-14
at Oberlin....................................W........................... 31-20

2021                                                    
Record: 3-7 (NCAC 2-7)
Coach: Rich Nagy
Captains: appointed each game
Thiel.......................................W.............................42-14
at Denison............................L........................... 31-0
at Wabash.............................L........................... 36-28
Ohio Wesleyan......................L...........................28-19
Kenyon..................................L........................... 27-13
at Hiram..............................W........................... 38-13
DePauw.............................L........................... 38-14
Wittenberg................................L.......................... 29-19
at Wooster..............................L........................... 59-41
Oberlin....................................W........................... 42-38

2022                                                 
Record: 3-7 (PAC 2-6)
Coach: Rich Nagy
Captains: appointed each game
Union....................................L.............................42-27
at Thiel...........................W........................... 34-6
at Westminster.............................L........................... 42-14
at Geneva......................L...........................35-21
Waynesburg......................W...........................31-15
at Washington & Jefferson.................L........................... 66-14
Grove City..............................L........................... 44-17
Saint Vincent.............................L........................... 52-35
Case Western Reserve.............L.......................... 54-7
at Bethany.............................W........................... 20-17 (OT)

2023                                            
Record: 3-7 (3-7 PAC)
Coach: Braden Layer
at Waynesburg....................W....................39-36 (OT)
Geneva....................L....................27-21
at Saint Vincent....................L....................23-19
Bethany....................W....................31-20
Carnegie Mellon....................L....................19-3
at Washington & Jefferson....................L....................35-28
Grove City....................L....................31-7
at Westminster....................L....................27-17
Thiel....................W....................27-3
Case Western Reserve....................L.....................42-14

2024                                        
Record: 1-9 (1-9 PAC)
Coach Braden Layer
at Bethany          W    20-14
Saint Vincent      L     41-20
Westminster       L     42-7
at Grove City      L      58-7
CWRU                L       58-14
at Thiel                L       21-7
at Geneva            L       30-13
Waynesburg        L        44-41
at Carnegie Mellon    L    63-10
W&J                        L        45-0