Allegheny College Athletics

First Team
Joe Killian (3B)	2016
Zach Gray (2B)	2015
Domenic Lanzilatti (OF)	2004
Scott Swinchock (P)	2001
Ben Couch (OF)	2001
Brad Hensler (SS)	2000
Jeff Mountain (P)	1999, 2000
Kevin Davidson (1B)	1999
Fran Riordan (1B)	1997
Mike Porada (2B)	1997
John Tavares (SS)	1996
Jason Nypaver (OF/1B)	1996
Joe Musgrove (OF)	1996, 97
Joe Rine (3B)	1995
Greg Reinhart ( c)	1995
Mike Penn (OF)	1994
Pat Broadwater (P)	1993
Steve Cook (P)	1992, 93
Craig Jones (OF)	1990
Jeff Bradic (OF)	1989
Rick Grimm (SS)	1988, 90
Tim Brudzewicz (P)	1987, 88

 

Second Team
Matt Jennings (OF)	2024
Chase Boyer (P)	2016
Mike Pereslucha (UTL)	2011
Matt Stahl (1B)	2010
Matt Dishong (P)	2010
Matt Young (SS)	2008
Rob George (P)	2001
Mark Minadeo (2B)	200
Ben Couch (OF)	1998, 99
Kevin Davidson (1B)	1998
Kevin Gang (OF)	1997
Fran Riordan (1B)	1996
Mike Penn (OF)	1993

 

Third Team
Tyson Bryant-Dawson	2025
Joe Killian (3B)	2015
Mike Pezzone (OF)	2014
Ben Lowmaster (C)	2011

 

Honorable Mention
Brad Yeschenko (2B)	1999
Brad Hensler (SS)	1998
John Tavares (SS)	1997
Chuck Stefanini (P)	1996, 97
Jarrod DePriest (P)	1995
Joe Rine (3B)	1994
Dean Peterson (P)	1993
Mike Pennington (P)	1993
Chris Nelson (P)	1993
Ed Taylor (OF)	1987

Updated 6/4/25