| Year |
Award |
Athlete(s) |
| 2009 |
All-American |
Jeramie Parker (11th), Chris Marker (14th) |
| All-Mideast Region |
Chris Marker (1st), Jeramie Parker (2nd), Zac Ross (15th), Tony Dipre (16th), Jake Zimmerman (25th), Ryan Sullivan (31st) |
| All-NCAC |
Jeramie Parker (1st), Chris Marker (2nd), Zac Ross (6th), Tony Dipre (7th), Jakeb Zimmerman (9th), Ryan Sullivan (15th), Ryan Hanson (19th), Matt Lacombe (21st) |
| 2008 |
All-American |
Tony Dipre (25th) |
| All-Mideast Region |
Zac Ross (7th), Tony Dipre (8th), Matt Hoy (10th), Jakeb Zimmerman (23rd), Ryan Sullivan (25th), Jeramie Parker (27th) |
| All-NCAC |
Zac Ross (2nd), Matt Hoy (4th), Tony Dipre (6th), Jakeb Zimmerman (9th), Jeramie Parker (13th), Ryan Sullivan (14th), Devon Flynnperrault (15th), Pat McLaughlin (20th) |
| 2007 |
All-Mideast Region |
Ryan Place (2nd), Chris Corkins (8th), Zac Ross (9th), Matt Hoy (16th), Ben Mourer (17th) |
| All-NCAC |
Ryan Place (1st), Ben Mourer (2nd), Zac Ross (4th), Chris Corkins (5th), Tony Dipre (7th), Matt Hoy (9th), Devon Flynnperrault (10th), Jakeb Zimmerman (17th) |
| 2006 |
All-American |
Ryan Place (6th), Marco Dozzi (23rd) |
| All-Mideast Region |
Ryan Place (3rd), Marco Dozzi (7th), Chris Corkins (11th), Matt Hoy (13th), Ben Mourer (20th) |
| All-NCAC |
Marco Dozzi (1st-Runner of the Year), Ryan Place (2nd), Chris Corkins (5th), Ben Mourer (7th), Matt Hoy (10th), Matt Smith (15th), Craig Ball (16th) |
| 2005 |
All-Mideast Region |
Chris Carrier, Ryan Place, Marco Dozzi, Devon Flynnperrault |
| All-NCAC |
Chris Carrier (Runner of the Year), Ryan Place, Devon Flynnperrault (Newcomer of the Year), Chris Corkins, Ben Mourer, Matt Hoy, Marco Dozzi |
| 2004 |
All-American |
Kevin Pool |
| All-Mideast Region |
Kevin Pool, Jeff Conroy, Chris Carrier, Marco Dozzi |
| All-NCAC |
Kevin Pool, Jeff Conroy, Chris Carrier, Marco Dozzi, Tim Ross, Ryan Place (Newcomer of the Year) |
| 2003 |
All-American |
Kevin Pool |
| All-Mideast Region |
Kevin Pool, Chris Carrier, Jeff Conroy |
| All-NCAC |
Kevin Pool, Chris Carrier, Jeff Conroy, Ben Mourer |
| 2002 |
All-Mideast Region |
Dan Princic, Kevin Pool, Jeff Conroy, Devin Halley |
| All-NCAC |
Dan Princic, Jeff Conroy, Kevin Pool, Devin Halley, Chris Carrier |
| 2001 |
All-Mideast Region |
Jeff Conroy, Kevin Pool |
| All-NCAC |
Jeff Conroy, Jason Betts |
| 2000 |
All-Mideast Region |
Brice Allen, Devon Halley, Dan Princic, Rob Shaw |
| All-NCAC |
Brice Allen, Devon Halley, Dan Princic, Rob Shaw |
| 1999 |
All-Mideast Region |
Brice Allen, Dan Princic |
| All-NCAC |
Brice Allen, Dan Princic, Rob Shaw |
| 1998 |
All-Mideast Region |
Dan Princic |
| All-NCAC |
Brice Allen, Mark Hudson, Rob Shaw, Ben Wyrick |
| 1997 |
All Mideast Region |
Kurt Krause, Mike Matott, Mark Hudson |
| All-NCAC |
Krause, Mattot, Hudson, Ben Wyrick, Brice Allen |
| 1996 |
All Mideast Region |
Mike Matott, Kurt Krause |
| All-NCAC |
Matott, Krause, Mark Hudson, Kevin Anthony |
| 1995 |
All-Mideast Region |
Frankie Adkins, Mike Matott |
| All-NCAC |
Adkins, Kurt Krause, Mike Matott, Weldon Thompson |
| 1994 |
All-Mideast Region |
Frankie Adkins, Mike Matott, Weldon Thompson |
| All-NCAC |
Adkins, Matott, Will Sickles, Thompson |
| 1993 |
All-Mideast Region |
Jerry Hall |
| All-NCAC |
Frankie Adkins, Hall |
| 1991 |
All-Mideast Region |
Rick Hughes |
| All-NCAC |
Hughes, Colin Knisely |
| 1990 |
All-Mideast Region |
Greg Haas, Knisely |
| All-NCAC |
Rick Hughes, Colin Knisely |
| 1989 |
All-NCAC |
Doug Casa, Jeff Lowenguth |
| 1988 |
All-NCAC |
Tim Cardwell, Jeff Lowenguth |
| 1987 |
All-NCAC |
Jeff Reed |
| 1986 |
All-NCAC |
|
| 1985 |
All-NCAC |
Tom Brewer, Paul Egbert, Chris Keim |
| 1984 |
All-NCAC |
William Broderick, Paul Egbert |
