BETHANY, W.Va. -- The Allegheny College football team concluded the 2022 season on a high note on a warm and sunny Saturday afternoon, as the Gators knocked off Bethany College in overtime, 20-17, thanks to the left foot of sophomore kicker
Garrett Paxton (Freedom, Pa./Freedom Area).
The 19-yard game-winning field goal was redemption for Paxton, who was responsible for all six points scored in the second half of what proved to be a defensive struggle. The second-year kicker had an opportunity to seal the victory in regulation, but his 35-yard attempt with one minute remaining in the fourth quarter was low and off the mark.
After Paxton hit the go-ahead kick, Bethany's (1-8, 0-8 PAC) offense stalled on its first three plays in overtime. Facing a fourth-and-10 from the 25, the Bison chose to go for the 42-yard field goal to force a second overtime, but the kick was well short.
With neither team able to get the passing game into a rhythm, the running backs carried both offenses. Allegheny (3-7, 2-6 PAC) relied on the one-two punch of
Tre Worship (East Cleveland, Ohio/Shaw) and
John Ian Duron (Coral Springs, Fla./J.P. Taravella), who combined for 61 carries and 208 yards on the ground. Duron led the duo with 107 yards, which included a 26-yard score in the second quarter, while Worship finished with 101 yards on a game-high 38 attempts.
Trailing 10-0 early in the second quarter, the Gators jump-started their comeback attempt on a big play from second-year quarterback
Trevor Brncic (Export, Pa./Franklin Regional). On a third-and-11, Brncic completed a 47-yard touchdown pass to
Declan O'Brien (Irwin, Pa./Norwin) for Allegheny's first points of the contest. Duron's 26-yard score gave the Gators a brief 14-10 advantage, but the Bison scored before the half and led at the break, 17-14.
The defense's made their impact on the game from the get-go. On back-to-back possessions early in the first quarter, both teams threw interceptions, the first of which was recorded by
Shane Cafardi (Gibsonia, Pa./Pine-Richland) on Bethany's first offensive play of the day.
David Babb (Pembroke Pines, Fla./Chaminade Madonna) added two picks in the third quarter.
Brothers
Fletcher Hammond (Gibsonia, Pa./Deer Lakes) and
Maxwell Hammond (Gibsonia, Pa./Deer Lakes) also combined for a turnover. The younger brother strip-sacked Bethany quarterback Marquice Robinson, and
Maxwell Hammond picked up the loose ball to set up Duron's touchdown-scoring drive in the second quarter.
Inside the Box Score
- Allegheny finished with 400 yards of total offense, with 213 yards on the ground and 187 through the air.
- Bethany finished with 313 total yards and had a slight advantage in yards per play at 4.7.
- Jack Johnson (Hingham, Mass./Hingham/Milford Academy) led Allegheny's QB duo with 109 yards, while Brncic passed for 78 yards on just two completions.
- Duron (107) and Worship (101) both surpassed 100 yards rushing.
- O'Brien caught two passes for a team-high 77 yards, including the 47-yard touchdown from Brncic.
- Defensive lineman Chris Rubino (Monaca, Pa./The Kiski School) led the Gators on defense with 13 total tackles, including one for a loss.
- Babb had seven tackles and two interceptions.
- LJ Orbovich (Pittsburgh, Pa./Carrick) and Fletcher Hammond each had a sack for the Gators.
- Paxton finished 2-for-3 on field goals with successful tries from 19 and 20 yards.
News and Notes
- Saturday's game marked the first between Allegheny and Bethany since 2009.
- The Gators improved to 18-15-1 in the all-time series, which began in 1926.
- The overtime win is Allegheny's first since defeating Wabash College, 20-17, on September 22, 2012.
- Allegheny's 400 yards of offense is the second-highest single-game total of 2022.
- Three interceptions are the most by the AC defense since the Gators had three in the 2021 opener against Thiel College.
- O'Brien tied a single-season career-best with his sixth touchdown reception and finished his junior year with a career-high 691 receiving yards.
- Duron went over 100 yards on the ground for the first time as a Gator, while Worship did so for the fourth time this fall.
- Rubino's 13 tackles are a single-game career-high.