Caitlin was named the MVP of the 2013 North Coast Athletic Conference softball championship tournament, where she threw every inning for the Gators, who captured the tourney championship with a win over Wittenberg in the finals. She threw a total of 26 innings, allowing just five earned runs (1.08 ERA) on an opponent batting average of .198, while striking out 30.  At the plate, she had three hits, including a double, and three RBI, with a sacrifice fly and sacrifice bunt over the tourney's three games.Â