| Had a player pass for 400+ yards |
410 yards, Jack Johnson, 11/6/21 at Wooster |
| Had a player pass for 300-399 yards |
360 yards, Trevor Brncic 10/19/24 vs. Geneva |
| Had a player pass for five touchdowns |
Jack Johnson, 11/13/19 vs. Oberlin |
| Had a player pass for at least four touchdowns |
Sean Siska, 11/15/25 vs. Bethany |
| Had a player catch three touchdown receptions |
3, Devin Larry, 11/1/25 vs. Westminster |
| Had a player with 200+ receiving yards |
Declan O'Brien, 205 yards, 11/6/21 at Wooster |
| Had a player with 150-199 receiving yards |
183, Devin Larry, 11/1/25 vs. Westminster |
| Had a player with 10+ receptions |
Chris Gisewhite, 11 receptions, 11/9/24 vs. Carnegie Mellon |
| Had 350+ passing/receiving yards |
410 yards, 11/6/21 at Wooster |
| Had 300+ yards team rushing |
300 yards (39 attempts), 9/16/06 vs. Hiram |
| Scored three rushing touchdowns |
9/20/25 vs. Thiel |
| Scored at least four rushing touchdowns |
10/22/22 vs Saint Vincent |
| Had a player rush for 100-149 yards |
Dominic Beraducci, 146 yards, 11/15/25 vs. Bethany |
| Had a player rush for 150+ yards |
Dominic Beraducci, 157 yards, 9/20/25 vs. Thiel |
| Had a player rush for 200+ yards |
Tre Worship, 201 yards, 9/24/22 vs. Waynesburg |
| Had a player rush for three touchdowns |
Tyler Balla, 11/10/18 at Oberlin |
| Had 500 yards of total offense |
528 yards, 11/6/21 at Wooster |
| Had a player with 200+ all-purpose yards |
Tre Worship, 213 yards, 9/24/22 vs. Waynesburg |
| Scored a special teams touchdown |
Terran Mitchell, 85 KR, 9/13/25 at Juniata |
| Held an opponent under 50 yards rushing |
12 yards, 11/2/19 vs. Hiram |
| Held an opponent under 100 yards passing |
59 yards, 10/26/19 at DePauw |
| Held an opponent under 150 total yards |
104 yards, 9/26/09 at Oberlin |
| Had 5+ sacks in a game |
6, 9/29/18 at Hiram |
| Had four interceptions in a game |
5, 10/20/18 at Kenyon |
| Had a player with 15+ tackles |
Kyle McGee, 21 tackles, 11/16/19 at Oberlin |
| Had a player with three sacks |
Colten Buzard, 9/30/17 vs. Hiram |
| Scored a defensive touchdown |
Landon Wayne, 83 yard interception return, 9/6/25 vs. Denison |
| Shut out an opponent |
Allegheny 49, Kenyon 0, 10/19/19 |
| Posted two consecutive shutouts |
at Earlham (67-0), at Kenyon (42-0), 1999 |
| Won an overtime game |
11/05/22, Allegheny 20, Bethany 17 |
| Played consecutive overtime games |
2008, vs. Wittenberg (30-27), vs. Ohio Wesleyan (10-7) |
| Blocked a field goal |
Aizik Campbell, 10/4/25 vs. Waynesburg |
| Blocked a punt |
Zach Wilson, 10/111/22 vs. W&J |
| Recorded a safety |
9/27/25 vs. Geneva |